Archive for the ‘Skills for life’ Category

I’ve often felt that Ofsted, the government body responsible for assessing quality in UK schools and Further Education,  is perceived by its customers in a similar way to the Inland Revenue. We may not like them but we know they’re necessary and we’re happy as long as they keep away from us.

But following the appointment of a new and more vocal Chief Inspector, the organisation has had more than its fair share of criticism. Headteachers have talked about ‘bullying tactics’ and the government now appears to be pondering a U-turn on its proposals for unannounced inspections.

In the corporate sector where company Apprenticeship and other government funded programmes are also subject to Ofsted inspection, there is a feeling that inspectors (most of whom are ex-school teachers) have little understanding of the commercial world and of the technological advances that are driving learning.  So it was no surprise during a recent review of one of our hugely successful  corporate Skills for Life programmes when one of our managers was told by an inspector who was about to spend a day with her learners: ‘I’ll tell you now that I can’t stand elearning!’ Not a good start to the day…

Yet despite the criticisms and concerns, most people accept that a robust system of quality assurance is essential. Both to ensure that government funding is being put to best use and that training providers are continually looking to improve. So what’s wrong with the present system and how can we improve it?

To reach an answer, I believe that we have to start with the classic four stage model of training evaluation:

  • Stage 1 – Assess the learner’s initial thoughts about the training programme. That’s fairly easy to do and “Happy Sheets” have been the staple fare of training providers for many years. However, whilst they may provide a warm fuzzy feeling (and the occasional shock) for the trainer, they are of little value in assessing the real impact (if any) of the training programme.
  • Stage 2 – Evaluate whether the learner has gained any knowledge. Again, it’s not rocket science and there are many tried and tested methods – exams, projects, diaries etc.

So far so good, but now it starts to get more complicated because Stages 3 and 4 evaluate whether  the learner’s behaviour has changed as a result of the training (are they doing things differently, acting more effectively?) and whether their organisation benefits as a result. These are longer-term changes and far more difficult to assess, but ultimately they are the purpose of any training programme.

My argument is that whilst Ofsted may be very good at evaluating Stages 1 and 2 of the training process,  in the corporate world they are simply not attempting to assess the longer-term impact of training on behavioural change and company performance. As such, their inspection ratings are inherently flawed and providers are left frustrated and disillusioned. ‘They just don’t get it’ is a phrase I have heard far too often.

So if Ofsted is going to evaluate the growing number of embedded corporate Apprenticeship programmes, then I believe they have to change their approach. The ‘Tick Box’ mentality  associated with Levels 1 and 2 assessment will need to morph into a more comprehensive and robust procedure if we are going to effectively assess whether government funded programmes are genuinely  resulting in skill development for learners and improved performance for the companies who employ them.

Image: FreeDigitalPhotos.net


Read Full Post »

Over recent weeks, government advisors and industry leaders have been lining up to highlight the skills problem in the UK workforce. For example, this is what John Longworth, director general of the British Chamber of Commerce, had to say:

“Companies need employees with the right mix of skills to grow their businesses. Almost two-thirds of businesses tell us they are unable to find the skilled workers they need in the UK . Developing the capability of our future workforce must be a priority. Too many young people have been failed by the education system and left unable to compete with non-UK workers who often have the skills businesses need.” (Source: The Telegraph)

I have discussed this issue in previous  posts and have unashamedly used the word “skills crisis” as opposed to
“problem” because that is what we are talking about. Unless we can find a way of upskilling  both the existing and future workforce, we will create a vast cohort of people who are not simply unemployed, but are unemployable. The social consequences of such a scenario hardly bear thinking about.

Clearly, we are not doing enough to encourage people to learn. A survey published this morning by the National Institute for  Continuing Adult Education (NIACE) produced the shocking results that nearly two thirds of adults have not participated in any learning since leaving full time education.

At MindLeaders, we are therefore delighted to be part of a consortium led by Calderdale College who have successfully bid for £55.7m in European Social Funding  (ESF) over the next three years, specifically to address the skills crisis. This funding is aimed primarily for low skilled people over the age of 19 currently in employment and will give them the chance to study for a Level 1 or Level 2 qualification. For many learners, this is likely to be their first ever qualification.

Very importantly, additional funding will be available for learners who then “progress” towards a higher level qualification and for people who gain promotion as a result of their training.  For me, this is a key feature of the funding programme. We want to encourage people not simply to participate in a single training course, but to develop a culture of learning which will enable them to progress further in their career  and fulfil their potential.

This funding will enable us to offer training programmes to many workers throughout the UK care and hospitality sectors in which we operate.  I don’t expect it to solve the skills crisis overnight, but if it starts to make an impact, then I for one will  be very proud.

Read Full Post »

Lead to Serve

Leadership Mastery

Anj Handa

I coach women leaders on becoming highly effective, authentic communicators.

OLC eLearning Landscape

Insight, Inspiration and Vision

Inquire Within

It's not about getting the right answers but rather, asking really good questions

Oxford University Press

English Language Teaching Global Blog

OBOlinx | Resources

Global Staffing Solutions and Management Consulting

Education Onion

Peeling back the layers of education - By Theresa Marriott @InspiringTeach

User Generated Education

Education as it should be - passion-based.

I've Been Thinking

My personal thoughts on the world of education

The State Of Ed Tech

Anything at the intersection of Education and Technology or #edtech ...


Learning to thrive with your career.


A Popular Source of Inspiration for Leaders all over the World



Global Grade 3

Connecting & Learning Beyond Classroom Walls

Leading in Context

Unleash the Positive Power of Ethical Leadership

Inspired Youth : Aspire to More

Our work and philosophy

Apprenticeship, Skills & Employability.

Content Curation - Apprenticeships, Skills & Employability

Good To Great

In pursuit of excellence: my view on the world of learning and training

Learning Activist

activating learning anyone anywhere